In the years when there was no selection of a Defensive Lineman of the Year, results only referred to Lineman of the Year
| 2024 - Noah Williams | |
| 2023 - Nkosi Stewart | 2011 - Rob Varallo |
| 2022 - Dylan Clarke | 2010 - Rob Bowman |
| 2021 - Jordan Fletcher | 2009 - Spencer Bogucki |
| 2019 - Soren Hallschmid | 2007 - Jason Nurse |
| 2018 - Brendan Hepburn | 2006 - Ashley Squires-Smith |
| 2017 - Elias Hajjar | 2005 - Ashley Squires-Smith |
| 2016 - Garrett Heming | 2004 - No Selection |
| 2015 - Matt Long | 2003 - Dave Stephenson |
| 2014 - Garrett Heming | 2002 - Phillipe Salloum |
| 2013 - Josh Franks | 2001 - No Selection |
| 2012 - Mike Walsh | 1975 - Eric Paivio |